$B:b@/L1 $B!=:b@/9=B$2~3W$K8~$1$?Ds8@!=(J

$BJdO@#2!%(J

$B=t309q$K$*$1$k:b@/9=B$2~3W$X$N
$B7P:Q3h@-2=$N$?$a$K$b:b@/9=B$2~3W$OI,MW$H9M$($k$,!"3$30$K$*$1$k:b@/9=B$2~3W$r$_$k$3$H$b!"$o$,9q$G:b@/9=B$2~3W$N$?$a$NL\I8$de$G6K$a$FM-MQ$K$J$k!#(J

  1. $BJF9q(J
    $B!]<+=u<+N)$N86B'$N$b$H$K:b@/6Q9U$rL\;X$9!](J

    2. $BJF9q$G$O(J80$BG/Be0J9_!":b@/@V;z$,3HBg$7$F$$$/$N$KH<$$!"9qL1$N4V$G:b@/@V;z$O9b6bMx$dL14VEj;q$N%/%i%&%G%#%s%0!&%"%&%H$r$b$?$i$7!">-Mh@$Be$KMxJ'$$Ey$NIiC4$rIi$o$;$k$b$N$H9-$/G'<1$5$l$k$h$&$K$J$j!"(J80$BG/BeH>$P0J9_$N%l!<%,%s@/8"!"$=$N8e$N%V%C%7%e@/8"$N$b$H$G:b@/<};Y6Q9U$K8~$13Fp@*$,;W$o$7$/$J$$Cf$G$O!"$3$&$7$? $B$3$&$7$?Cf$GH/B-$7$?%/%j%s%H%s@/8"$O(J93$BG/$KJq3gE*7P:Q@/:v$rH/I=$7!"G/!93HBg$r0lES$rC)$k:b@/@V;z$r:o8:$9$k$?$a$N%W%m%0%i%`$H$7$F!"Jq3g:b@/D4@0K!(J(OBRA93)mail protected])$5$;!"%a%G%#%1%"(J($BO7Np7$$$?$,!"%/%j%s%H%s@/8"$O$=$l$r>h$j1[$($F2~3W$KF'$_@Z$C$F$$$k!#(J

    $B$^$?!":P=PA}2CM^@)$N$?$a$N;EAH$_$H$7$F$O!"Bh(J1$B$K!"M=;;$N(J1/3$B$r@j$a$k:[NLE*7PHq$K$D$$$F$O>e8B3[(J($B#C#A#P(J)$B$r@_Dj$7!"$3$l$rD6$($?>l9g!":[NLE*7PHq$,>e8B$NOHFb$K$*$5$^$k$h$&!"0lN'$K:o8:$r9T$&$3$H$H$7$F$$$k(J($B2H(J)$B!#B>J}!";D$j$NM=;;Am3[$N(J2/3$B$r@j$a$k5AL3E*7PHq$K$D$$$F$b!"?7$?$K:P=PA}$K$D$J$,$kAl9g!"5AL3E*7PHq$KBP$9$k0lN':o8:$,9T$o$l$k$3$H$H$7$F$$$k(J(pay-as-you-go$B86B'(J)$B!#(J

    $B8=:_!"%/%j%s%H%s@/8"$O(J2002$BG/$N:b@/<};Y6Q9U$rL\;X$7$F!"99$K:b@/9=B$2~3W$K
    $B:[NLE*7PHq$K78$k>e8B(J($BC10L!%2/%I%k!"!s(J)
    $BG/EY(J9192939495969798
    $B:[NLE*7PHq$N>e8B(J
    ($B?-$SN((J)    		 5,516
    ($B!=(J)    		5,457
    (-1.1)    		5,504
    (0.9)    		5,459
    (0.8)    		 5,467
    (0.1)    		5,480
    (0.2)    		5,487
    (0.1)    		5,485
    (-0.0)

  2. $B%I%$%D(J
    $B!];:6H3h@-2=$K$h$k8[MQAO=P$K8~$1$F!](J

    3. 90$BG/$+$i$NEl@>E}0l$KH<$&:P=PA}$HIT67$K$h$k@G<}$N?-$SG:$_$K$h$j!":b@/@V;z$N=L>.$,Bg$-$J2]Bj$H$J$C$F$$$k!#B>J}!"7P:Q>p@*$b;W$o$7$/$J$/!"Bg6%Ah$H$$$&@$3&E*$JN.$l$NCf$G!"=>Mh$+$i$N9b%3%9%HBN.$5$J@/I\$N$7$J$Ic@)EY$N;W$$@Z$C$?2~3W$d9q:]6%AhNO$N6/2=$K;q$9$k4k6H@G@)$N8+D>$7Ey$r9T$&$3$H$H$7$F$$$k!#$^$?!"El@>E}0l$K$h$jKDD%$7$?O"K.@/I\$N?M7oHq!J8xL30w?tLs(J38$BK|?M(J)$B$r:o8:$9$k$?$a!"L11D2=$J$I;W$$@Z$C$?9T@/2~3W$rCG9T$7$?$[$+!"8xL30w$N5kM?$NM^@)$KF'$_@Z$C$?!#:#8e$H$bO"K.@/I\$O8xL30w?t$r:o8:$9$k$3$H$H$7$F$*$j!"El@>E}0lA0$N5l@>%I%$%D$N?e=`(J($BLs(J30$BK|?M(J)$B$KLa$9$3$H$r:G=*E*$JL\I8$H$7$F$$$k!#(J

    $B%I%$%D$G$O:b@/L\I8$rC#@.$9$k$?$a$NO!W$dJF9q$N(Jpay-as-you-go$B86B'$K6a$$!V%b%i%H%j%"%`86B'!W$r:NMQ$7$F$$$k$[$+!"#5%+G/$N!VCf4|:b@/7W2h!W$r:vDj$7$F$*$j!"(J7$B7n$K3U5D7hDj$7$?(J97$BG/$NO"K.M=;;0F$G$O!"$3$N7W2h$K4p$E$-!":P=PAm3[$OA0G/Hf(J2.5$B!s8:$H(J2$BG/O"B3$N%^%$%J%9$H$J$C$?!#(J

    $BCf4|:b@/7W2h!JC10L!!2/%^%k%/!"%+%C%3Fb$OA0G/EYHfA}8:!s!K(J
    $B#9#5(J$B#9#6(J$B#9#7(J$B#9#8(J$B#9#9(J
    $B:P!!=P(J$B#4(J,$B#7#7#7(J
    		$B#4(J,$B#5#1#3(J
    $B!J!]#5(J.$B#5!K(J    		 $B#4(J,$B#4#0#2(J
    $B!J!]#2(J.$B#5!K(J    		$B#4(J,$B#4#7#3(J
    $B!J#1(J.$B#6!K(J    		$B#4(J,$B#5#8#7(J
    $B!J#2(J.$B#5!K(J
    $B:P!!F~(J$B#4(J,$B#2#8#7(J$B#3(J,$B#9#1#4(J$B#3(J,$B#8#3#7(J$B#3(J,$B#9#1#1(J$B#4(J,$B#0#3#3(J
    $B:b@/@V;z(J$B#4#9#0(J$B#5#9#9(J$B#5#6#5(J$B#5#6#2(J$B#5#5#4(J

  3. $B1Q9q(J
    $B!]8x6&%5!<%S%9$N8zN(2=$K$h$k>.$5$J@/I\$rL\I8$K!](J

    4. $B?MF,@GF3F~LdBj$J$I$+$i<-G$$7$?%5%C%A%c!$K$b$H$E$-6!5k%5%$%I$N2~A1$rB%?J$9$k$3$H$r@/:v$N4pK\%9%?%s%9$H$7$F$$$k!#6qBNE*$K$O!"cHq$NA}2CM^@)(J($B0eNE$N<+8JIiC4$N0z>e$2!"G/6b$N5kIU?e=`$N0z$-2<$2(J)$B!"8x6&;v6HHq$N:o8:!"9qM-4k6H$NL11D2=(J($B1Q9qEE5$DL?.8x $B$^$?!"9T@/$N8zN(2=$rL\;X$7$F!"%7%A%:%s%:!&%A%c!<%?!<$rBG$A=P$7!"c!"(J93$BG/EYM=;;$+$i$O%3%s%H%m!<%k!&%H!<%?%k$H$$$&;EAH$_$rF3F~$7!"8xE*;Y=P$+$i<:6Hc;Y=P$dCf1{@/I\MxJ'Hq5Z$SL11D2=<}F~$r=|$$$?ItJ,$N $B$=$N7k2L!"3HBg$7$F$$$?:b@/@V;z$O!"(J94-95$BG/EY$K$O=L>.$7$F$*$j!"(J90$BG/Be=*$o$j$^$G$K6Q9U$9$k$b$N$H4|BT$5$l$F$$$k!#(J

    $B%3%s%H%m!<%k!&%H!<%?%k(J
    $B3F>J$N35;;MW5a$,9T$o$l$?8e!"@/I\A4BN$H$7$F$N8~$3$&(J3$BG/4V$N;Y=PAm3[$N>e8B$r<($7$?%3%s%H%m!<%k!&%H!<%?%k$r7hDj$9$k!#$=$7$F!"$3$NOHFb$K;Y=P$rM^$($k$h$&!"6qBNE*$J:n6H$,9T$&!#(J

    1995-961996-971997-981998-99
    $B$B7W!!2h(J
    $B%3%s%H%m!<%k!&%H!<%?%k(J
    ($B     		2,555
    (0.25)    		2,602
    (-1.0)    		2,682
    (0.5)    		2,756
    (0.5)
    $B7J5$=[4D$K:81&$5$l$k(J
    $BItJ,$Nc;Y=P(J
    $B!J<:6H     		140139142147
    $BCf1{@/I\MxJ'Hq(J 205223240240
    $B$=$NB>(J 96979196
    $B0lHL@/I\:P=P!?#G#D#P(J 4240 1/239 3/438 3/4

  4. $B%+%J%@(J
    $B!]@/<# 90$B!"(J91$BG/$N%^%$%J%[email protected]$dBP#G#D#PHfN($G2a5n:G9b$N(J5.9$B!s$K$N$\$C$?:b@/@V;z(J($BO"K.@/I\(J)$B$rGX7J$K(J93$BG/$NAmA*5s$G$O!"M?E^?JJbJ]
  5. $BO"K.@/I\?&0w(J(32$BK|?M(J)$B$N(J14$B!s:o8:$rCl$H$9$k@/I\ItLg$N9gM}2=!"(J
  6. $B9bNpc5kIU6b$N:o8:!"<:6HJ]81@)EY%W%m%0%i%`$NJQ99$J$I$Nc@)EY2~3W!"(J
  7. $B=#@/I\$X$N8rIU6b%+%C%H!";:6H8~$1Jd=u6b$NBgI}:o8:!"G@6HJd=u6b$NGQ;_(J

$BEy$N:o8::v$r9V$8$k0lJ}$G!"2J3X5;=Q?66=$J$I$K$D$$$F$O=EE@E*$KM=;;$rG[J,$7$F$$$k!#$^$?:PF~LL$G$O%,%=%j%s@G!"$?$P$3@G$J$I$NA}@G$r $B$^$?!"%+%J%@@/I\$O:P=P9=B$$NH4K\E*$J8+D>$7$r9T$&$?$a!"%W%m%0%i%`!&%l%S%e!<$H$$$&%f%K!<%/$J$7$d8z2L$NI>2A$r5a$a$k$b$N$G$"$k!#$3$NF3F~$K$h$k $B0J>e$N$h$&$JEXNO$,
$B%W%m%0%i%`!&%l%S%e!<$K$*$1$k@/I\;Y=P$N#6$D$N4p=`(J
  1. $B$=$N;E;v$O8x1WA}?J$K4sM?$9$k$+!#(J(Public Interest Test)
  2. $B@/I\$,$=$NLr3d$r2L$?$9$3$H$,I,MW$+$D9gM}E*$G$"$k$+!#(J(Role of Government Test)
  3. $B$=$l$OO"K.@/I\$G$J$/!"COJ}$,2L$?$9$Y$-Lr3d$G$O$J$$$+!#(J(Federalism Test)
  4. $B$=$N;E;v$NA4It0?$$$O0lIt$rL14V$K0\$9$3$H$,2DG=$+!#(J(Partnership Test)
  5. $B$=$N;E;v$K$h$C$F$I$NDxEY8zN(@-$,8~>e$9$k$N$+!#(J(Efficiency Test)
  6. $B:b8;$KM>M5$,$J$$Cf$G$b$=$N;E;v$OI,MW$J$N$+!#(J(Affordability Test)

$B%+%J%@$N:b@/@V;z=L8:$N8z2L(J
$B!J2/%+%J%@%I%k!"!s!K(J
$B#9#3(J$B#9#4(J$B#9#5(J$B#9#6(J$B#9#7(J
$B:b@/@V;z=L8:9g7W3[(J $B#1#5(J$B#1#3#0(J$B#2#1#5(J$B#2#6#1(J$B#2#8#9(J
$B$&!!$A!!:P!!=P(J $B#7(J$B#1#0#6(J$B#1#8#9(J$B#2#3#3(J$B#2#5#6(J
$B:P!!F~(J $B#8(J$B#2#4(J$B#2#6(J$B#2#8(J$B#3#4(J
$B:b@/@V;zBP(JGDP$BHfN((J -5.9-5.0-4.2-3.0-2.0

$B!v%^!<%F%#%sB"Aj$O(J10$B7n(J9$BF|5D2q$KBP$9$kG/.$5$;$k$H=R$Y$?!#(J

  • $B%K%e!<%8!<%i%s%I(J
    $B!]9-HO$+$DBgC@$J7P:Q9=B$2~3W$rCG9T!](J

    • 1960$BG/Be$K@$3&6~;X$NK-$+$5$r8X$C$?%K%e!<%8!<%i%s%I$O(J2$BEY$N@PL}4m5!$r7P$F7P:QIT?6$K4Y$C$?!#$H$/$K:b@/$NB&LL$G$O!":PF~$,?-$SG:$`0lJ}!"cHq$,A}2C$7$?$?$a!"@V;z$,3HBg$7!"(J83$B!?(J84$BG/EY$N9q$N:b@/@V;z$O$D$$$KBP#G#D#PHf$G(J6.5$B!s$KC#$7$?!#(J84$BG/$NA*5s$G>!Mx$7$?O+F/E^@/8"$O!"$3$&$7$?>u67$rC&$9$k$?$a!";T>l5!G=$r=E;k$7$?7P:Q9=B$$X$NE>49$rL\;X$7$F!"!VDK$_!W$rH<$&9=B$2~3W$K4VHfN($N8+D>$7$r9T$C$?!#$^$?!"9T@/2~3W$K$bG.?4$K 90$BG/$NA*5s$G@/8"$r0z$-7Q$$$@9qL1E^$O99$K2~3W$r?d$7?J$a$?!#9qL1E^$OO+F/E^$,$G$-$J$+$C$?8[MQ7@LsK!(J($BAH9g$rDL$5$:$K8[MQ@\8D?M$H7@Ls$r7k$V$b$N$H$9$kK!(J)$B$N@)Dj$dJ!;c4XO"M=;;$N:o8:$r9T$C$?$?$a!"(J93$BG/$NA*5s$G$O6l@o$r6/$$$i$l$?$b$N$N!"6O:9$G>!Mx$r$*$5$a$?!#$=$7$F!"(J94$BG/$K$O:b@/@UG$K!$r@)Dj$7!"9q:D;D9b$NBP#G#D#PHfN($r(J97$B!?(J98$BG/EY$^$G$K(J30$B!s0J2 $B%K%e!<%8!<%i%s%I@/I\$,$3$&$7$?Bg2~3W$r2DG=$K$7$?M}M3$H$7$F$O!"(J
    1. $B@/<#$,6/$$%j!<%@!<%7%C%W$r$b$C$FL?7|$1$G$B9-HO$JJ,Ln$G2~3W$r9T$&$3$H$G!"4{F@8"h$j1[$($?$3$H!"(J
    $B$J$I$,$"$2$i$l$F$$$k!#(J

    $BF|K\8l$N%[!<%`%Z!<%8$X(J